After allegedly not receiving a satisfactory response to a C&D letter, American outdoor sportswear clothing manufacturer and patent holder Volcom Inc. has just filed a patent infringement lawsuit against competitor Holden LLC (Case No.8:11-cv-00269 California Central District Court).
The patent at issue in the case is No. 7,874,019 “Powder skirt zipper system” (elastic bands snuggly fitting the waist while attaching to the inside of a jacket) which discloses a jacket having a powder skirt and trousers that can be attached to the powder skirt via at least one fastener.
One of the embodiments of the Volcom invention includes a water resistant jacket with an elasticized powder skirt having two edges, one attached to the jacket, the other to the pants, thus sealing off the wearer from the snow.
Volcom, which campaigns to make skateboarding, surfing and snowboarding competitions free under the “Let the kids ride free” banner, points in the complaint to specific features of certain Holden garments that are allegedly infringing the patent.
The case is rare in the apparel industry in that it does not address the more common issues of trademarks, they are quite distinct in this case, or copyrights or design patents, as most features in this field are functional and thus not eligible for this type of protection. Rather, the specific competitive innovation is covered by a recently issued patent. These facts, and the risks of a potential injunction, lead us to expect a close and short battle in court.
From the perspective of potential patent infringement damages calculations, an important issue is the damages period, which typically starts no sooner than the issue date of a patent. In this case, one point of view would be that infringing sales have only been accruing since the issue date 45 days ago. This aspect would lead us to expect an increased priority for an injunction. We shall continue to monitor the case.
You must be logged in to post a comment.